IMAP vs POP3 vs JMAP: which email protocol should you use?
IMAP, POP3 and JMAP explained — what each protocol does, which mail apps use them, and why IMAP is the default choice in 2026.
The team behind Manuel Mail
When you add a custom-domain mailbox to Apple Mail, Outlook or Thunderbird, you're choosing a protocol: IMAP, POP3, or increasingly JMAP. The choice determines whether your mail lives on the server or your device, whether multiple devices stay in sync, and how much battery and data you burn. Here's the plain-English version.
IMAP — the default answer
IMAP (Internet Message Access Protocol) keeps your mail on the server and syncs it to every device you add. Read a message on your phone, it's marked read on your laptop. Delete a folder on desktop, it's gone everywhere. For anyone using more than one device — which is everyone — IMAP is the correct choice and what virtually every mail app defaults to.
POP3 — the legacy option
POP3 (Post Office Protocol) downloads mail to one device and (usually) deletes it from the server. It made sense in the dial-up era of single computers; today it causes exactly the problems you'd expect — mail trapped on one laptop, 'disappearing' messages when you switch devices, and no webmail access to what was downloaded. Avoid it unless you have a specific archival reason and understand the trade-offs.
JMAP — the modern protocol
JMAP (JSON Mail Access Protocol) is the newer standard designed to fix IMAP's age: faster sync through efficient JSON queries, better push notifications, and a cleaner API for modern apps. Fastmail built it and it's gaining adoption — but client support is still catching up. If your provider offers it and your app supports it, it's the best experience; IMAP remains the safe universal fallback.
Quick comparison
- Sync across devices — IMAP ✅ · POP3 ❌ (one device) · JMAP ✅
- Works everywhere — IMAP ✅ (universal) · POP3 ✅ · JMAP ⚠️ (growing)
- Webmail access — IMAP ✅ · POP3 ⚠️ (only what wasn't downloaded) · JMAP ✅
- Efficiency — IMAP okay · POP3 good (less syncing) · JMAP best (designed for it)
- Future-proof — IMAP aging · POP3 legacy · JMAP the modern standard
What about sending?
Receiving and sending are separate protocols — IMAP/JMAP/POP3 handle incoming mail; SMTP handles outgoing. Any decent provider gives you both: IMAP + SMTP settings (ports 993/465 for encrypted IMAP and SMTP) or JMAP for everything if the client supports it. Our mail clients doc has the exact settings for Apple Mail, Outlook and Thunderbird.
Rule of thumb for 2026: choose IMAP for compatibility, JMAP if your app offers it, and forget POP3 exists.